Choosing the right flavor carrier is one of the most important steps in getting the results you want. The carrier affects how a flavor mixes, how it behaves, and how it performs in different applications.
This guide breaks it down simply, based on what you are making.
Beverages
Best choice: Water-soluble (PG-based)
Water-soluble flavorings are designed to mix evenly into liquids without separating. They disperse cleanly and consistently, making them the most reliable option for drinks.
Common beverage uses include:
-
Water and flavored waters
-
Sodas
-
Syrups
-
Teas and lemonades
-
Energy and wellness drinks
Avoid: Oil-soluble flavors, as they do not mix evenly into water-based liquids and may separate.
Candy, Chocolate, and Confections
Best choice: Oil-soluble
Oil-soluble flavorings are commonly used in candy and confectionery because they perform well in high heat and low moisture environments. They blend smoothly into sugar and fat-based recipes without introducing water.
Common confection uses include:
-
Hard candy
-
Lollipops
-
Chocolate
-
Caramels
-
Fudge
Water-soluble flavors can introduce moisture, which may affect texture, clarity, or stability.
Baking
Best choice: Depends on the recipe
Baking recipes vary widely, so both water-soluble and oil-soluble flavorings can work when matched correctly.
General guidance:
-
Use water-soluble flavors for batters, frostings, icings, and glazes
-
Use oil-soluble flavors for richer, high-fat recipes
Matching the carrier to the dominant base of the recipe helps ensure even flavor distribution.
Lip Products, Balms, and Cosmetic Applications
Best choice: Oil-soluble or MCT-based
Oil-soluble and MCT-based flavorings blend well into oils, waxes, and balms without separating. This makes them suitable for lip and cosmetic-style applications.
Common uses include:
-
Lip balm
-
Lip gloss
-
Oil-based cosmetic products
-
Salves
Only flavors labeled as appropriate for cosmetic or lip use should be used in these applications.
Mixing and Blending Flavors
Flavors can be blended to create custom profiles as long as the carrier type is the same.
Recommended combinations:
-
Water-soluble with water-soluble
-
Oil-soluble with oil-soluble
-
Powdered with powdered
Mixing different carrier types together is not recommended, as it can lead to separation or uneven flavor.
A Simple Way to Remember
-
Drinks and liquids: water-soluble
-
Candy, chocolate, and fats: oil-soluble
-
Baking: depends on the recipe
-
Lip and cosmetic products: oil-soluble or MCT
When in doubt, match the carrier to the base of what you are making.
Final Note
Using the right carrier helps avoid separation, uneven flavor, and wasted product. Once you understand which carrier fits your application, flavoring becomes simpler, more consistent, and more predictable.
